The sheer number of start ups continues unabated. Some
address new opportunities and warrant a closer look, but many often fail to
deliver their elevator pitch. Many make sense, but little money, others make
little sense but still attract money, a mere handful become successful and are
often eaten up by larger organisations.
One that we found very interesting is the US start up
Bookmooch, which is a used book exchange.
Users list their books that they want to trade, getting credits for those listed. When another
user takes one of the books the seller gets additional credits. No money
changes hands and all that is paid out is the postage by the seller. The
acquired credits from trading can then be used to acquire other books. In
rewarding the giving of books with credits that can only be used at the
exchange, Bookmooch has created a virtual circle of engagement. However one can
only benefit if the book you want is in the exchange so Bookmooch also allows
members to create wish lists and if their needs are not available they have the
option to buy them seamlessly from Amazon. Members can also provide feedback on
the titles they acquire. There are no membership fees, no trading fees and
Bookmooch makes money through advertising and Amazon referral commission.
The site has been operating for 6 years, and
has a quarter of a million members. The
“give one and acquire another” approach
has much appeal to those with bulging bookshelves who are looking for new reads.
Many may question whether a free exchange can make
serious money as what money it makes is out of secondary services. We would
suggest that with the numbers it is attracting both in active members and usage
the opportunity is real. The information it is collecting on demand, listings,
demographics etc and on backlist titles itself has real value. However if, or
should that be when, the first sale doctrine on ebooks gets addressed its model
and appeal could take off. This again raises the thorny issue of the current
pricing and licensing of ebooks and whether the current arrangement is in the
consumer interest and sustainable.
